I recently read the article by Mike Moffatt entitled "FairTax - The Advocates Strike Back". I appreciate the opportunity given to Mr. Al Ose to respond to the initial article by Mr. Moffatt about the FairTax on. Since tax reform is an important economic issue, it is important to debate the merits of good tax reform ideas, such as the FairTax.
I have an issue with one part of the article by Mr. Moffatt, in which he states:
I have not changed my opinion greatly on the FairTax. I do not think it ever has a chance of being passed and I do not think it will have the great benefits to the economy that its supporters claim. However, I want my readers to have access to the largest amount of information possible, so I'm happy to provide them with alternative points of view.
I have the following responses to the above paragraph by Mr. Moffatt:
1. "I do not think it ever has a chance of being passed" - In debating of ideas, this would not be my first concern, but rather what are the best ideas. I think ideas should be considered first, not based on the prospect of it passing, but rather on the merits of the proposal. Additionally, I think Mr Moffatt underestimates the impact a well organized, intelligent, informed, and enthusiastic grop of individuals can have. There is no doubt that enacting the FairTax will be a tough challenge, but speaking for myself, it is well worth the time and effort to try.
2. "I do not think it will have the great benefits to the economy that its supporters claim" - A vague statement such as that is hard debate since there are no data or facts to dispute. I would like to see a response to the very detailed argument presented by Mr. Al Ose, which is based on seven years of research with a $22-million budget. However, until data and facts can be presented to support your claim, your statement lacks the necessary facts to be considered a serious rebuttal.
3. "However, I want my readers to have access to the largest amount of information possible, so I'm happy to provide them with alternative points of view." - That is an admirable point of view to have. I just hope that Mr. Moffatt can maintain a open mind to new ideas, and not become another critic caught up in the inertia of the current , an ineffective, system of taxation.
