1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Economics

The Executive's Local Constituencies (Part 2)

The Executive's Local Constituencies

From Adam Romney, About.com Guest

These two cases illustrate that the logic behind granting the executive power to negotiate free trade agreements so that he can be a force for liberalization is flawed on two levels. First, it ignores that the structures inherent in the election of the executive reward candidates for acting like a legislator. Being able to claim victories for crucial acts in swing states is important for any executive attempting to capture re-election. As long as votes are grouped by geographic district, presidents will attempt to cater to votes on that level. If the President were truly held accountable to a national constituency, Oatley's logic would be correct. However, currently the President is held accountable to 50 local constituencies, some of which he knows in advance he will not be able to please. Thus, while it may be more difficult for the President to push the costs of protectionism onto others, it is still definitely possible. In the wake of the 2000 election, the impacts that the Electoral College has on American trade policy should surely be taken into account when discussing the executive's tendency to pursue free trade.

Secondly, the theory fails to take into account that because the president acts as a policy leader for his political party, he too has a stake in bills that are on the floor of Congress. As a result he can be forced to make concessions just like any individual legislator. On trade policy, this can mean the president is susceptible to logrolling. This turns the logic behind the RTAA and similar measures upside down. Rather than viewing the executive as a cure-all for liberalizing trade, perhaps future legislation should turn the ability to negotiate free trade agreements over to a semi-independent figurehead, much like the position currently occupied by Alan Greenspan. This figurehead could have a term long enough to not tie him to any specific president and thus be relatively immune from congressional politics. This new office would realize Oatley's logic on a whole new level, because far from having a national constituency, the independent office would have no direct constituency to pressure him away from doing what's best for the country. Until these structural and political reforms are adopted, the RTAA and legislation like it will fail to produce a liberalized trade policy that maximizes societal welfare.

Be Sure to Continue to Page 7 of "The Executive's Local Constituencies".

Explore Economics

About.com Special Features

A Smarter Future

Tips that will help finance your education, excel in the classroom, and advance your career. More >

How to Ace the GRE

Being well prepared is the first step; here are more essential suggestions. More >

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Economics

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.