1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Economics

Presidential Elections and the Economy

Incumbents Who Won

By Mike Moffatt, About.com

Out of our six presidential elections, we had three where the incumbent won. We'll look at those three, starting with the percentage of the electoral vote each candidate collected.
  1. 1956: Eisenhower 57.4%, Stevenson 42.0%

    Real GNP growth (Economy):
    Two Year: 4.54%
    Four Year: 3.25%
    Previous Administration: 4.95%

    Unemployment Rate (Jobs):
    Two Year: 4.25%
    Four Year: 4.25%
    Previous Administration: 4.36%

    Although Eisenhower won in a landslide, the Economy had actually performed better under the Truman administration than it did during Eisenhower's first term. Real GNP, however, grew at an amazing 7.14% per year in 1955, which certainly helped Eisenhower get reelected.

  2. 1984: Reagan 58.8%, Mondale 40.6%

    Real GNP growth (Economy):
    Two Year: 5.85%
    Four Year: 3.07%
    Previous Administration: 3.28%

    Unemployment Rate (Jobs):
    Two Year: 8.55%
    Four Year: 8.58%
    Previous Administration: 6.56%

    Reagan won in a landslide, which certainly had nothing to do with the unemployment statistics. The economy came out of recession just in time for Reagan's reelection bid, as real GNP grew a robust 7.19% in Reagan's final year of his first term.

  3. 1996: Clinton 49.2%, Dole 40.7%

    Real GNP growth (Economy):
    Two Year: 3.10%
    Four Year: 3.22%
    Previous Administration: 2.14%

    Unemployment Rate (Jobs):
    Two Year: 5.99%
    Four Year: 6.32%
    Previous Administration: 5.60%

    Not quite a landslide, we see quite a different pattern than the other two incumbent victories. Here we see fairly consistent economic growth during Clinton's first term as President, but a consistently improving unemployment rate. It would appear that the economy grew first, then the rate of unemployment decreased, which we would expect since the unemployment rate is a lagging indicator.

If we average out the three incumbent victories, we see the following pattern:
    Incumbent 55.1%, Challenger 41.1%

    Real GNP growth (Economy):
    Two Year: 4.50%
    Four Year: 3.18%
    Previous Administration: 3.46%

    Unemployment Rate (Jobs):
    Two Year: 6.26%
    Four Year: 6.39%
    Previous Administration: 5.51%

It would appear then from this very limited sample that voters are more interested in how the economy has improved during the tenure of the presidency than they are in comparing the performance of the current administration with past administrations.

We'll see if this pattern holds true for the three elections where the incumbent lost.

Be sure to continue to Page 3 of "Presidential Elections and the Economy".

Explore Economics

About.com Special Features

A Smarter Future

Tips that will help finance your education, excel in the classroom, and advance your career. More >

How to Ace the GRE

Being well prepared is the first step; here are more essential suggestions. More >

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Economics
  4. Taxes, Policy, & Politics
  5. Elections & The Economy
  6. Presidential Elections and the Economy

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.